Georgia Tech Procurement Assistance Center

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Training
    • Class Registration
    • On-demand Training
    • GTPAC COVID-19 Resource Page
    • Cybersecurity
    • Veterans Verification Video
    • GTPAC Community
    • Other Training Audio & Video
  • Useful Links
  • Team Directory
    • Albany Counselor
    • Atlanta Counselors
    • Augusta Counselor
    • Carrollton Counselor
    • Columbus Counselor
    • Gainesville Counselor
    • Savannah Counselor
    • Warner Robins Counselor
  • Directions
    • Atlanta – Training Facility
    • Atlanta – Office
    • Albany
    • Augusta
    • Carrollton
    • Columbus
    • Gainesville
    • Savannah
    • Warner Robins
  • COVID-19
  • New Client Application
  • Contact Us

Post hoc proposal reevaluation exacerbates error in award decision

August 8, 2016 By Andrew Smith

GAO-GovernmentAccountabilityOffice-SealThe Government Accountability Office (GAO) released on July 15, 2016 a public version of Delfasco, LLC, B-409514.3 (March 2, 2015), a decision noteworthy because of how the GAO dealt with an agency’s post hoc reevaluation of proposals.

The protestor, Delfasco, LLC (Delfasco), had an incumbent contract to sell dummy practice bombs to the U.S. Army, and it protested the award of a follow-on contract to GTI Systems, Inc. (“GTI”), a competitor.

While Delfasco’s protest was pending before the GAO, the Army reevaluated the offerors’ proposals, and it found errors in its evaluation.  The Army increased Delfasco’s past performance rating, and it eliminated three strengths that had been assigned to GTI’s technical proposal.  Nonetheless, the Army concluded that these errors would not have altered its award decision.  In its final brief to the GAO, the Army explained this reevaluation.  The Army asserted that Delfasco had not been prejudiced, and it asked the GAO to deny Delfasco’s protest.

Keep reading this article at: https://www.insidegovernmentcontracts.com/2016/07/post-hoc-proposal-reevaluation-exacerbates-error-in-award-decision/

Filed Under: Contracting News Tagged With: Army, award protest, bid protest, evaluation, evaluation criteria, GAO, past performance, post hoc evaluation, proposal, proposal evaluation

Recent Posts

  • DLA hosting event March 10th with special emphasis on Women-Owned Small Businesses
  • Navy Office of Small Business Programs holding three events in March
  • SBA hosting conversations with contracting officers forum Feb. 25th
  • Final rule, formal training on CMMC could hit this summer
  • Non-compete clauses in government contracting: a case study in enforceability

Popular Topics

8(a) abuse Army bid protest budget budget cuts certification construction contract awards contracting opportunities cybersecurity DoD DOJ False Claims Act FAR federal contracting federal contracts fraud GAO Georgia Tech government contracting government contract training government trends GSA GSA Schedule GTPAC HUBZone innovation IT Justice Dept. marketing NDAA OMB SBA SDVOSB set-aside small business small business goals spending subcontracting technology VA veteran owned business VOSB wosb

Contracting News

Final rule, formal training on CMMC could hit this summer

COFC: “Rule of two” must be analyzed before “any” acquisition

DOD’s cybersecurity certification requirements to appear in DHS contracts

Congressional Research Service publishes updated report on SBA’s 8(a) program

Congressional Research Service publishes new report on SBA’s HUBZone program

Read More

Contracting Tips

Non-compete clauses in government contracting: a case study in enforceability

NDAA for fiscal year 2021 includes numerous provisions impacting government contractors

Beware of the automated email response

Complying with the government’s restrictions on foreign telecommunications equipment

Construction claims in the COVID era: lessons learned and best practices

Read More

GTPAC News

DLA hosting event March 10th with special emphasis on Women-Owned Small Businesses

Navy Office of Small Business Programs holding three events in March

SBA hosting conversations with contracting officers forum Feb. 25th

USACE seeks vaccination center construction support

GTPAC updates cybersecurity resource page to include CMMC guidance

Read More

Georgia Tech News

Collective worm and robot “blobs” protect individuals, swarm together

The Partnership for Inclusive Innovation is now accepting applications for pilot programs

Georgia Tech will help manage DOE’s Savannah River National Laboratory

Dr. Abdallah testifies on U.S. competitiveness, research, STEM pipeline at Congressional hearing

Georgia Tech’s Technology Square Phase III to include George Tower

Read More

  • SAM.gov registration is free, and help with SAM is free, too
APTAC RSS Twitter GTPAC - 30th Year of Service

Copyright © 2021 · Georgia Tech - Enterprise Innovation Institute